Gimmick Vol. 1 (Kuroko Yabuguchi, Young Jump)
This manga is only worth a peek to see the difference the artist can make. The author of this series also wrote the solid Kindaichi Case Files and the quality difference between the two manga is, at least when comparing the first volumes of each, pretty big. I don’t have much else to say about this book. It’s an episodic action series where the do-gooder main character uses his special effect creating abilities to foil evil creeps and save cute girls. The only moderately curious thing here was how many moments of gory violence this volume contained, and how all of the gore is eventually revealed to be a special effect. It comes across like a lazy way to force the reader to re-examine his/her reaction to violence, or something.
Selected Pandemonium Vol. 3 (Ichiko Ima, Nemuki)
It’s becoming clearer and clearer that this series is not going to live up to the promise of the (awesome) first volume. I feel kind of bad about my reaction here since I haven’t really fallen for any mainstream series done by a yaoi artist and this is arguably the best. For those who don’t know, this series falls squarely in to the “person who can see the undead” genre. The two dull leads frequently get involved in the activities of spirits, that only they can see. The revelations and conclusions are usually throw-aways but the build up is well crafted. I particularly liked the one story where the main character suspects the boyfriend of a guest is behind a series of murders. It’s just disappointing when you find out some spirit was behind it all.
Card Captor Sakura Vol. 3 (Clamp, Nakayoshi)
This is single handedly my favorite volume of this bunch though I have a difficult time explaining why. The first part of the volume revolves around the mirror card. It’s taken up Sakura’s image, which is confusing people. It’s no big secret that this series is about images, so this scenario was bound to crop up eventually. There’s one scene where Sakura puts her faith in a fortune revealed by her clow cards. To me, it seemed funny that she’d be so trusting of images, when it’s that same attitude from those around her that’s causing trouble.
The climax is built around the discovery that the mirror card is going to attack Sakura’s brother, and that Sakura must rush to him and defeat the card before he is killed. Roughly, that’s what happens. The difference is in the interaction between the card and Sakura’s brother. I won’t go in to all the details, but the card actually comes to care deeply for him. The atmosphere of this series is extremely upbeat, cute, unthreatening, ect, so it was interesting that found compassion was used as a substitute for danger and uneasiness.
This also sort of ties in to the second part of volume, which revolves around the shield card. Apparently the shield card has locked up an important case belonging to Sakura’s friend Tomoyo. The defeating and capturing of the shield card is a non-event but what’s revealed after the case is opened is another story. The items inside the case represent fond memories and feelings for Tomoyo and her mother. Some of them are shared with Sakura and well, some are kept hidden.
O-Parts Hunter Vol. 11 (Seishi Kishimoto, Shonen Gangan)
This is easily the weakest volume since the end of that initial government oppressors arc. To me it seemed like to much pointless world background and plot mechanics. What did jump out at me, more than it had previously, were the references to science facts and such. I haven’t checked to see if the information mentioned in the book are facts, and it’s somewhat besides the point if they are or not. The most interesting use of this was immediately after the fight between (fire user) Jin and (ice user) Shuri. More then just being at elemental odds, the two have different philosophies towards revenge and have been trying to convince the other that they’re wrong throughout the battle. Rather then letting the victory of the battle reflect the superiority of one point of view, the reader is informed that there is a limit on the coldest temperature but not on the hottest, so the hottest fire would inherently defeat the coldest ice. Hence the philosophical beliefs of the fighters were actually independent of the scientific laws of the manga’s world.